Language Selection

English French German Italian Portuguese Spanish

Mini Distro Round-Up

Filed under
Reviews

I went to distrowatch and looked for the 5 smallest distros I could find. I found my old pal Damn Small Linux, new comers Puppy Linux, Feather Linux, BeatrIX, and Sam.

I sampled each of those listed above and will share my thoughts and screenshots of them with you. I also thought to make it more fair, I'd outline and define some criteria for them to meet. Not scientific, but I chose five areas that I considered important in which a mini distro should excel. Each distro has the opportunity to earn 5 points for each of the 5 areas. Then I will divide that total by 5 to get their final score of between 1 and 5 points.

  • Size:
  • The smallest in the lot was 50mb, so that was my starting point. In my tests and for the purposes of this article, smaller is better.

  • Ease of Use:
  • Is it easy to boot up and get into a gui? Are the tools and applications readily available and easy to find, and easy to use?

  • Looks:
  • Simply put, how pleasing is it to the eye?

  • Useful:
  • Are the apps included useful and are they useful to a majority of users? Is there something included to complete most any basic task? This area is most simply put, how useful is the distro?

  • Stability and Functionality:
  • Is the distro stable and are the applications stable? Do they function as designed and complete their tasks?


The Contenders

Damn Small Linux is the coolest thing in my book if for no other reason than it's itty bitty size. To get a fully functional operating system complete with X server in 50 mb is quite the accomplishment. I found it and puppy linux to have met that criteria. damn small linux claims to be able to run light enough to power a 486DX with 16MB of Ram.

dsl is a complete operating system containing a mighty powerful toolbox. in it's gui you'll find office tools such as a spreadsheet, several editors and a couple word processors, as well as graphic manipulation/editing tools. It comes with games, multimedia applications, and system monitoring tools. Included are the means for a harddrive install and even application installation and updating. There are tools for your networking options and connecting to remote desktops, virtual file systems, and even ftp servers. Found are file managers, web browsers, mail and instant messaging clients. Of course it goes without saying, it also comes with a full compliment of commandline tools. Most applications were carefully chosen for their balance of functionality, stability, and size.

Being built upon Knoppix, dsl's hardware detection was good and fairly accurate. Most of my hardware was detected and the correct module was inserted accordingly. My network connection worked automagically, it having used dhcp. The X server booted into a nice looking Fluxbox desktop with 1024x768 resolution.

I found dsl to be fast, stable, fully functional and a wondrous thing. It was my favorite of all the mini-distros I sampled. I've always been a fan and even until a recent harddrive death, had a permanent install of it taking up about 250 mbs. And it's got the coolest name! Big Grin

Screenshots

Puppy Linux was just a big bag of surprizes from the moment it began to boot until I logged out. This was my first test drive of puppy linux, so perhaps that contributed to my impression. The first notable was the amazing lack of time it took to boot. It had to have been no more than 30 seconds before I was looking at a question about which mouse dev I wanted to use. I choose imps/2 and wondered if it would work, yes it did. It asked did I have a scroll wheel, and within 2 seconds of clicking yes I was presented with a gui.

Upon entering the auto-logged in gui, I was asked which resolution I wanted to use. Choosing 1024x768x16 seemed like a good choice, it adjusted and staring at me was a nice fvwm desktop. The menu reminded me of a cross between kde's and windows', but the start button did come with a cute little puppy icon. Inside that menu was a plethora of software. It's hard to believe this was from a 56mb iso.

My internet connection wasn't enabled automagically, but a simple "dhcpcd" command was all that was needed to surf the internet and even my lan's samba shares.

Import and xwd weren't installed, but xpaint can take screenshots, even if a bit cumbersome. Looking around lo-and-behold there was a menu entry for xpaint gui screenshots. Well, I didn't like all that clicking to get a screenshot and man xpaint opened a browser with the commands I could use.

The menu was chocked full of applications. There were gui apps for about everything from configuring the desktop, monitoring the system, connecting to about everything under the sun, to all sorts of movie and music players. I was throughly impressed. Not only did it have a couple browsers, but it had at least two html editors. It even had a puppy-get software installer. Some of the utilities present were backup to cd, F-Prot virus scanner, and guiTar archiver. Also included was a menu item for a gui mount tool, which was nice because I couldn't get the mount command to work. It kept saying such and such directory didn't exist. I suppose it had to do with it's method of ramfs. But it did find and let me mount a partition/directory in which I could save my screenshots.

Puppy Linux seemed to derive from Debian and came with a 2.4.27 kernel. It was a wonderful wonderful little distro. I was thoroughly impressed, I might have to put that one on it's own partition somewhere. Smile Kudos to the developers.

Screenshots

Feather Linux is the prettiest mini distro so far, also based on Knoppix and comes with a 2.4.27 kernel. A little larger than dsl or puppy weighing in at a 120mb. Like puppy, it boots really fast and asks some configuration questions along the way. Default lang and keyboard are german, I had to specify lang=us at boot. As puppy did it asked what kinda mouse I had and in what resolution I wanted X to run, and in addition it asked about default keymap.

The desktop was just pretty as all get out with cute tux wallpaper and nice icons. Default desktop is fluxbox and it's using a nice matching theme.

It's menus were full of apps, maybe not as much as puppy seemed, but still quite a toolkit. It comes with all the standard applications for web browsing, im, irc, email, ftp, ssh, samba, word processing, image manipulation, various multimedia capabilities, and standard commandline apps and built-ins. It was fast, stable and complete.

The author describes it as "a Linux distribution which runs completely off a CD or a USB pendrive and takes up under 115Mb of space. It is a Knoppix remaster (based on Debian), and tries to include software which most people would use every day on their desktop."

Screenshots

BeatrIX Linux is a whoping 183mb, yet it seemed to have the less to offer. This developer chose to go with a few big heavy apps as opposed to our other candidates who went with a more complete outfit of smaller applications. BeatrIX does come with a browser, an instant messenger, an email and an office app. But they are about the biggest heaviest example of each. Mozilla-Firefox, Gaim, Evolution, and OpenOffice are kinda big and slow applications. I didn't see a graphical file manager. I suppose with 6 full page consoles of binaries tho, it's bound to have had one - just no desktop icon or menu entry for it. To top it off, it's all sitting on Gnome 2.8 and running on a 2.6.7 kernel. It does have a cute start up slogan though: BeatrIX - Linux that purrs.

BeatrIX is named after a cat and the developers stress that it isn't designed for multimedia. They state, "it simply works and is easy to learn and use. Months were spent on designing the desktop to be as usable as possible the first time you insert the BeatrIX CD."

It was slower than it's competition so far, and it's by far not the prettiest. But it does indeed do as it's designed. It's still relatively small, but it won't fit on my mini-cds. All and all, BeatrIX just isn't my cup of tea. I imagine gnome fans might like it though.

Screenshots

Sam Linux "is a bootable Linux-CD based on Mandrakelinux, an installation on harddrive is not necessarily, but possible. Because of the small size of under 210mb it fits on a 8cm-mini-CD and is ideal for carrying in the pocket. Although it is so small, it contains a full graphical desktop environment with office-, internet-, multimedia- and graphics-applications, even some games and a small server-section are there." ...so they say.

It is also the only distro in this round-up that won't run on my desktop computer. It booted, but then locked up as it tried to enter X. In fact it locked up so hard that I had to hit reset...

So, anyway, it will run on my older computer with an ati rage 128 and I was able to gleen some information from there. I wasn't able to get screenshots as it locked up solid as I was trying to su to root. The password is supposed to be "root" according to the site, but it was rejected and on the third try it locked the computer up tight as a drum. I'm not trying anymore.

Sam appears to be using Xfce for it's window manager with gnome commander, velocity, midnight commander, and Xffm listed as file managers. It comes with Dillo and Firefox for web browsing, Sylpheed for email and Pan for newsreading. Included is gaim for instant messaging, Xchat for irc and Skype for voip. Sam is the first one of our minis to use TextMaker for it's word processing, to include a personal finance tool and something to use your bttv card for watching tv. It even comes with gimp and more than just a few games. Also included are the Mandrake Control Center, firestarter and a harddrive installer.

So, all in all, this distro is as buggy as it's roots. I can't recommend Sam Linux as I didn't even get to test drive it much past menu navigation before it locked up.

Luit Linux is another 50mb mini distro based on damn small linux. It's getting long in the tooth as the lastest release I saw was July 2004. It's using a 2.4.22-xfs kernel dated September 2003 underneath an older XFCE. However it did fine on my system, hardware newer than that kernel date.

It booted quickly and performed well. It had some applications for doing basic tasks and all seemed stable except for it's choice in a spreadsheet app. It didn't open when clicked upon. Otherwise it's another adequate mini, although I wasn't highly impressed. I suppose it's stagnating development was a turn-off from the start.

Screenshots

The Verdict


Distro Size Ease Looks Useful Stab/Funct total/5
Damn Small 5 4 3 4 5 4.2
Puppy 5 3 3 4 5 4
Feather 4 4 5 4 5 4.4
BeatrIX 3 4 2 3 4 3.2
Sam 2 3 3 2 0 2
Luit 5 3 3 3 4 3.8


In conclusion, I still like damn small linux the best although puppy linux is a very close second. Seems the points favor feather linux, and it was indeed the prettiest. Any of these three can fill the bill for about any rescue or convenient take along purpose you might have. Beatrix is too big and heavy for no more than it offers and Sam, well, my mama said if you can't say anything nice...

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

re: I concur!

I don't know why Sam didn't want to run here. At first I thought it must be my newer video card, a geforce 6800oc, but then it locked up with an old ati rage 128 too. I'm using AMD 2800+ barton on a MSI KT4AV (kt400) with crucial pc2700 ddr in one and a 2200+ thunderbird on a Abit KX7-333 (kt333) with kingston pc2700 in the other.

I wish I had seen this link yesterday tho, I'da skipped the Sam report altogether. Tongue

----
You talk the talk, but do you waddle the waddle?

re: Be l337 with Luit!

yep, that's the one I was talking about wishing I had seen the link yesterday. I saw it today on pclo after writing my article. I've already downloaded it and burnt it, but I'm having issues with my slave server, so I may not get around to updating my article with it's coverage.

In addition, am I just not seeing a newer release than last July?

thanks.

----
You talk the talk, but do you waddle the waddle?

Updated to include Luit.

Thanks for the encouragement, I updated the article to include Luitlinux.

----
You talk the talk, but do you waddle the waddle?

re: It seems that Flonix is not r

I saw it listed on distrowatch and looked at the site, but it looked like usb was the only method. This seems to be the download link. I guess I could have made it work on cdr. Perhaps I dismissed it too quickly. Well, it's back to the salt mines today. I'll have to save that one for another day.

----
You talk the talk, but do you waddle the waddle?

re: They all seem to borrow from DSL

Yep, I noticed that too.

Thanks! Smile

----
You talk the talk, but do you waddle the waddle?

oh ok, I see

Yeah, that link posted yesterday in a previous reply /was/ for a bootable cdrom. I was running too late yesterday and looked at it too quickly. I guess the bootable usb key could be nice for some tho. But I don't know when it might be /more/ convenient than a mini cd. Anyone know any examples?

----
You talk the talk, but do you waddle the waddle?

re: new puppy

wow, you should have submitted that as news. Smile

sounds wonderful.

----
You talk the talk, but do you waddle the waddle?

re: Wot about the Latvians?

I spent a coupla days clicking on about every link at distrowatch to look at the size of the iso trying to find the 5 or 6 smallest. Perhaps we can do a part 2 or something.

Thanks for your comments! Smile

----
You talk the talk, but do you waddle the waddle?

re: future of tiny Linux?

I hear ya! I think that's why I have such a soft spot for mini distros. It takes development to a whole new level by trying to keep the download at 50 mb while still remaining (relatively) full featured.

And yes there are several that I didn't get to look at then. So many Linuxes, so little time. Big Grin

----
You talk the talk, but do you waddle the waddle?

TinyMe?

You should have tried TinyMe instead of SAM, IMO. It's more in the same vein as Puppy and DSL. It's a shame you didn't get SAM working. It's a very good distro.

re: tinyme

This is an older article. TinyMe wasn't around then. Sam became much more usable subsequently and TinyMe is very nice as well.

More in Tux Machines

today's howtos

Leftovers: Ubuntu

  • IOTA: IoT revolutionized with a Ledger
    Ever since the introduction of digital money, the world quickly came to realize how dire and expensive the consequences of centralized systems are. Not only are these systems incredibly expensive to maintain, they are also “single points of failures” which expose a large number of users to unexpected service interruptions, fraudulent activities and vulnerabilities that can be exploited by malicious hackers. Thanks to Blockchain, which was first introduced through Bitcoin in 2009, the clear benefits of a decentralized and “trustless” transactional settlement system became apparent. No longer should expensive trusted third parties be used for handling transactions, instead, the flow of money should be handled in a direct, Peer-to-Peer fashion. This concept of a Blockchain (or more broadly, a distributed ledger) has since then become a global phenomenon attracting billions of dollars in investments to further develop the concept.
  • Return Home and Unify: My Case for Unity 8
  • Can netbooks be cool again?
    Earlier this week, my colleague Chaim Gartenberg covered a laptop called the GPD Pocket, which is currently being funded on Indiegogo. As Chaim pointed out, the Pocket’s main advantage is its size — with a 7-inch screen, the thing is really, really small — and its price, a reasonable $399. But he didn’t mention that the Pocket is the resurrection of one of the most compelling, yet fatally flawed, computing trends of the ‘00s: the netbook. So after ten years, are netbooks finally cool again? That might be putting it too strongly, but I’m willing to hope.

Linux Devices

  • Compact, rugged module runs Linux or Android on Apollo Lake
    Ubiqcomm’s 95 x 95mm, Apollo Lake-based “COM-AL6C” COM offers 4K video along with multiple SATA, USB, GbE, and PCIe interfaces, plus -40 to 85°C operation. Ubiqconn Technology Inc. has announced a “COM-AL6C” COM Express Type 6 Compact form factor computer-on-module built around Intel’s Apollo Lake processors and designed to withstand the rigors of both fixed and mobile industrial applications. The module offers a choice among three Intel Apollo Lake processors: the quad-core Atom x5-E3930, quad-core x5-E3940, and dual-core x7-E3950, which are clocked at up to 2.0GHz burst and offer TDPs from 6.5 to 12 Watts.
  • Internet-enable your microcontroller projects for under $6 with ESP8266
    To get started with IoT (the Internet of Things), your device needs, well, an Internet connection. Base Arduino microcontrollers don't have Internet connectivity by default, so you either need to add Ethernet, Wi-Fi shields, or adapters to them, or buy an Arduino that has built-in Internet connectivity. In addition to complexity, both approaches add cost and consume the already-precious Arduino flash RAM for program space, which limits what you can do. Another approach is to use a Raspberry Pi or similar single-board computer that runs a full-blown operating system like Linux. The Raspberry Pi is a solid choice in many IoT use cases, but it is often overkill when all you really want to do is read a sensor and send the reading up to a server in the cloud. Not only does the Raspberry Pi potentially drive up the costs, complexity, and power consumption of your project, but it is running a full operating system that needs to be patched, and it has a much larger attack surface than a simple microcontroller. When it comes to IoT devices and security, simpler is better, so you can spend more time making and less time patching what you already made.
  • Blinkenlights!
  • Blinkenlights, part 2
  • Blinkenlights, part 3
  • [Older] Shmoocon 2017: The Ins And Outs Of Manufacturing And Selling Hardware
    Every day, we see people building things. Sometimes, useful things. Very rarely, this thing becomes a product, but even then we don’t hear much about the ins and outs of manufacturing a bunch of these things or the economics of actually selling them. This past weekend at Shmoocon, [Conor Patrick] gave the crowd the inside scoop on selling a few hundred two factor authentication tokens. What started as a hobby is now a legitimate business, thanks to good engineering and abusing Amazon’s distribution program.
  • 1.8 Billion Mobile Internet Users NEVER use a PC, 200 Million PC Internet Users never use a mobile phone. Understanding the 3.5 Billion Internet Total Audience
    As I am working to finish the 2017 Edition of the TomiAhonen Almanac (last days now) I always get into various updates of numbers, that remind me 'I gotta tell this story'.. For example the internet user numbers. We have the December count by the ITU for year 2016, that says the world has now 3.5 Billion internet users in total (up from 3.2 Billion at the end of year 2015). So its no 'drama' to know what is 'that' number. The number of current internet total users is yes, 3.5 Billion, almost half of the planet's total population (47%).

Leftovers: OSS and Sharing

  • Rewriting the history of free software and computer graphics
    Do you remember those days in the early nineties when most screensavers were showing flying 3D metallic logotypes? Did you have one? In this article, I want to go back in time and briefly revise the period in the history of computer graphics (CG) development when it transitioned from research labs to everyone's home computer. The early and mid-1990s was the time when Aldus (before Adobe bought the company) was developing PageMaker for desktop publishing, when Pixar created ToyStory, and soon after 3D modeling and animation software Maya by Alias|Wavefront (acquired by Autodesk). It was also a moment when we got two very different models of CG development, one practiced by the Hollywood entertainment industry and one practiced by corporations like Adobe and Autodesk. By recalling this history, I hope to be able to shed new light on the value of free software for CG, such as Blender or Synfig. Maybe we can even re-discover the significance of one implicit freedom in free software: a way for digital artists to establish relations with developers. [...] The significance of free software for CG On the backdrop of this history, free software like Blender, Synfig, Krita, and other projects for CG gain significance for several reasons that stretch beyond the four freedoms that free software gives. First, free software allows the mimicking of the Hollywood industry's models of work while making it accessible for more individuals. It encourages practice-based CG development that can fit individual workflows and handle unexpected circumstances that emerge in the course of work, rather than aiming at a mass product for all situations and users. Catering to an individual's needs and adaptations of the software brings users work closer to craft and makes technology more human. Tools and individual skill can be continuously polished, shaped, and improved based on individual needs, rather than shaped by decisions "from above."
  • ONF unveils Open Innovation Pipeline to counter open source proprietary solutions
    ONF and ON.Lab claim the OIP initiative to bolster open source SDN, NFV and cloud efforts being hampered by open source-based proprietary work. Tapping into an ongoing merger arrangement with Open Networking Lab, the Open Networking Foundation recently unveiled its Open Innovation Pipeline targeted at counteracting the move by vendors using open source platforms to build proprietary solutions.
  • [FreeDOS] The readability of DOS applications
    Web pages are mostly black-on-white or dark-gray-on-white, but anyone who has used DOS will remember that most DOS applications were white-on-blue. Sure, the DOS command line was white-on-black, but almost every popular DOS application used white-on-blue. (It wasn't really "white" but we'll get there.) Do an image search for any DOS application from the 1980s and early 1990s, and you're almost guaranteed to yield a forest of white-on-blue images like these:
  • More about DOS colors
    In a followup to my discussion about the readability of DOS applications, I wrote an explanation on the FreeDOS blog about why DOS has sixteen colors. That discussion seemed too detailed to include on my Open Source Software & Usability blog, but it was a good fit for the FreeDOS blog.
  • Building a $4 billion company around open source software: The Cloudera story
    Dr Amr Awadallah is the Chief Technology Officer of Cloudera, a data management and analytics platform based on Apache Hadoop. Before co-founding Cloudera in 2008, Awadallah served as Vice President of Product Intelligence Engineering at Yahoo!, running one of the very first organizations to use Hadoop for data analysis and business intelligence. Awadallah joined Yahoo! after the company acquired his first startup, VivaSmart, in July 2000. With the fourth industrial revolution upon us—where the lines between the physical, digital and biological spheres are blurred by the world of big data and the fusion of technologies—Cloudera finds itself among the band of companies that are leading this change. In this interview with Enterprise Innovation, the Cloudera co-founder shares his insights on the opportunities and challenges in the digital revolution and its implications for businesses today; how organizations can derive maximum value from their data while ensuring their protection against risks; potential pitfalls and mistakes companies make when using big data for business advantage; and what lies beyond big data analytics.
  • What we (think we) know about meritocracies
    "Meritocracy," writes Christopher Hayes in his 2012 book Twilight of the Elites, "represents a rare point of consensus in our increasingly polarized politics. It undergirds our debates, but is never itself the subject of them, because belief in it is so widely shared." Meritocratic thinking, in other words, is prevalent today; thinking rigorously about meritocracy, however, is much more rare.
  • A new perspective on meritocracy
    Meritocracy is a common element of open organizations: They prosper by fostering a less-hierarchical culture where "the best ideas win." But what does meritocracy really mean for open organizations, and why does it matter? And how do open organizations make meritocracy work in practice? Some research and thinking I've done over the last six months have convinced me such questions are less simple—and perhaps more important—than may first meet the eye.
  • OpenStack Summit Boston: Vote for Presentations
    The next OpenStack Summit takes place in Boston, MA (USA) in May (8.-11.05.2017). The "Vote for Presentations" period started already. All proposals are now again up for community votes. The period will end February 21th at 11:59pm PST (February 22th at 8:59am CEST).
  • [FOSDEM] Libreboot
    Libreboot is free/opensource boot firmware for laptops, desktops and servers, on multiple platforms and architectures. It replaces the proprietary BIOS/UEFI firmware commonly found in computers.
  • Three new FOSS umbrella organisations in Europe
    So far, the options available to a project are either to establish its own organisation or to join an existing organisation, neither of which may fit well for the project. The existing organisations are either specialised in a specific technology or one of the few technology-neutral umbrella organisations in the US, such as Software in the Public Interest, the Apache Software Foundation, or the Software Freedom Conservancy (SFC). If there is already a technology-specific organisation (e.g. GNOME Foundation, KDE e.V., Plone Foundation) that fits a project’s needs, that may well make a good match.
  • ESA affirms Open Access policy for images, videos and data / Digital Agenda
    ESA today announced it has adopted an Open Access policy for its content such as still images, videos and selected sets of data. For more than two decades, ESA has been sharing vast amounts of information, imagery and data with scientists, industry, media and the public at large via digital platforms such as the web and social media. ESA’s evolving information management policy increases these opportunities. In particular, a new Open Access policy for ESA’s information and data will now facilitate broadest use and reuse of the material for the general public, media, the educational sector, partners and anybody else seeking to utilise and build upon it.
  • Key Traits of the Coming Delphi For Linux Compiler
    Embarcadero is about to release a new Delphi compiler for the Linux platform. Here are some of the key technical elements of this compiler, and the few differences compared to Delphi compilers for other platforms.