Language Selection

English French German Italian Portuguese Spanish

How to Perfectly Kill a Perfect Distribution

Filed under
PCLOS

PCLinuxOS was the perfect distribution in 2007. It had all the bells and whistles to be an excellent Windows XP alternative.

When a distribution is able to configure my hardware, is ultra stable, highly updated and provide me with almost all the required software then I think that is the distribution I am looking for. PCLOS had all these abilities and more. That's the reason it was called the distro-hopper stopper. People loved it and it rose to the pinnacle of Distrowatch Page hit rankings. Not only reached; it stayed there for a good 6 months. If we consider that the distribution PCLOS dethroned was mighty Ubuntu, that makes PCLOS achievement even more impressive. On one hand Ubuntu had the backing of Canonical - they were sending free CDs, had tieup with the likes of Dell, had dozens ( maybe more ) developers working; on other hand there was PCLOS which had a very small dev team and no corporate backing, no big computer assembler backing them.

Yet PCLOS rose to top on account of sheer merit. It had the novelty to generate interest and the quality to sustain it. Kudos to Textar and PCLOS 2007. It was almost perfect.

Alas! that was 2007, however, this is 2008 and almost end of 2008. A lot has changed since then.

More Here




re: Perfect Kill

This guy will be eating his hat in another two or three years when the 2007 respin is released.

fundamental misconcetion about pclos

My impression is that he doesn't fully understand the concept of rolling release. I am running PCLOS on a relatively recent Vaio, just like him, and have everything up to date, including the kernel.

Well, I'm happy

Like the author, I'm in a new country, new job, new computers, etc. After I moved I had Sabayon, Mandriva 2008 and Mint on my Comp but I went back to Pclos, namely Minime. It works fine on my new comp (Athlon 6.4, 4 gig ram and GF 8600) I configured it the way I want it and I'm not a bleeding edge kind of guy so if the apps work then they work for me. The only niggle has been the webcam but it didn't work under other distros (free from work so not bought for linux compatability). It seems quicker than the others and it is what I'm used to. As for some of the crits - the desktop?? Most users would customise it anyway. Auto login?? Isn't the pclos way better - new users should get used to the idea of security. It is easy to change anyway. I was never happy about the Ubuntu way of doing things anyway.
Pclos, IMO is still a great distro for converts from xp and those who don't need everything brand spanking new. It works and works well on new and old hardware. Us pclos users waited for 2007 and were happy with the rolling release. I still know some who are using Big Daddy. I'm happy waiting for 2008 as I have the distro set up the way I like it.

Re: Kill a Distro

PCLOS is a "garage distro", with a small number of devs, and is heavily dependent on 1 person for packaging and release.

Yes, the install iso 2007 should have been updated with a newer kernel with newer drivers earlier this year. Even for a rolling release distro, an occasional respin of the iso would make it possible to install it on newer hardware. For example, I couldn't get PCLOS 2007 to install on a system with an ASUS M2M-VM-DVI motherboard. Some experimentation indicates that an install with this particular motherboard requires kernel >= 2.6.25. Since my main box has PCLOS running under a newer kernel, I used "remasterme" to build my own updated ISO. Clearly, this is not a general purpose solution.

This kind of malaise often happens with small "garage distros" ... it's certainly happened with Mepis and slackware and others.

Texstar seems to be somewhat of a perfectionist, and releases slowly. But, if you want a distro that, once you get it installed and updated, works really well ... then PCLOS may be for you.

We all get impatient for the latest stuff. Indeed, I have Mandriva 2009 RC running on my experimental box, running all the latest stuff. But, to get real work done, I use my PCLOS box. It's still a wonderful distro (and I've tried dozens). And, I'm sure that the long delayed 2008 release will be too.

PCLinuxOS is top notch

First, atangf, Suse started life as a fork of Slackware, but isn't based upon anything Slackware does. The same goes for Mandriva. It was originally Red Hat + KDE, but it's completely built and developed in-house. This is quite different from some other distros, like Ubuntu, that rely heavily on a parent distro, such as Debian. PCLinuxOS is sort of half and half. They get their initial base off of Mandriva, so they start with a lot of Mandriva SRPMs and compile them as PCLinuxOS packages with no modification at all. Then there are some packages such as Mandriva Control Center that get modified and packaged. And, there are other packages that don't come from Mandy at all, but from Suse, Fedora, or just source and get packaged. Once that happens, and the rebased ISO is released, all subsequent packages are built completely from original source. That's what happened with the original PCLinuxOS release and 2007. All subsequent releases use packages completely built by the development team from source. Those releases contain the original base's core packages such as gcc and development libraries, but everything else is totally in-house. Not moving to a newer gcc and libraries allows the distro to be a "rolling release" distro. That means PCLinuxOS 2007 is highly compatible with Mandriva 2007, but not later releases. This is quite different from distros that almost completely rely on a parent distro's development. Most Debian based distros rely heavily on Debian's work.

Now that that's cleared up, a new PCLinuxOS release is very, very near. I'm not a developer, so I don't know the inside story as to the holdup, but it's a small developer team and stability is first and foremost. I do know, however, with some inside knowledge, that a new release is very, very near. This should erase any problems the author encountered. But, since it is a rolling release, it's pretty much up-to-date if just updated regularly. There won't be a whole lot different, but it will hugely affect those that boot the CD with newer hardware.

The author had some really minor gripes, honestly. KDE 4.x is, by KDE's own admission, not ready for production systems. Those that run it are on the bleeding edge. It was determined by the developers and mostly agreed upon by the community, that KDE 4.x is not ready and shouldn't be the default desktop. I believe the new release will also still use KDE 3.5.9 as the default desktop. When KDE finally gets the feature set complete and becomes rock solid, then it will be included as the default environment. Most early users of KDE 4.x have done nothing but complain about it, even in the media.

KDM is in the LiveCD is because you can login as root to install it, or just log in as user to run it. Some people use the LiveCD to run on other computers, and some use it to just install it. It might be just a feasible to just login everyone as root, or just allow the installation from the user account, but why give people bad habits? New users should learn to become used to the user/administrator setup of Nix from the very beginning.

Unlike some distros that try to protect the users from themselves, PCLinuxOS allows the user to login as root if they have root access. This has been debated in the forum and the majority agrees that they like access to their root account via KDM. This is quite different from auto login, where your little brother could boot your system and be in your account, rummaging through your personal email or wreaking havoc on your system. I don't see the author's point on this one.

I could just keep going, but I'll stop here. It's a nothing but a difference in opinion here. Some people prefer the habits of Slackware over others, some Ubuntu, some Gentoo, some PCLinuxOS. This is why there are so many distros out there. PCLinuxOS takes a decidedly different course when it comes to your Linux experience than that of Ubuntu, where the user is much more control and there is absolutely no command line knowledge needed in PCLinuxOS. Ubuntu works most of the time, but when it doesn't, things have to be configured either by hacking a file or a command line entry. It's two roads to the same destination.

Like I said, we know PCLinuxOS 2007 is a little long in the tooth, but a new full release is very near, and hopefully will alleviate any problems anyone should encounter.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

More in Tux Machines

Linux on Servers

  • Kontena Launches Container Platform, Banks Seed Funding
    Startup Kontena has launched a container and microservices platform that, it claims, is designed to be developer friendly, easy to install and able to run at any scale -- attributes that, Kontena says, differentiate it from the current crop of container platforms. The Menlo Park, Calif.-based company, founded in March 2015, has also raised $2 million seed funding from Helsinki-based Lifeline Ventures. It also has a clever name: Say it out loud -- cute, huh? According to the team at Kontena Inc. , the startup's container and microservices platform requires zero maintenance, is designed for automatic updates, and runs on any infrastructure, including on-premises, cloud and hybrid. Combined, those attributes make it an easy-to-use alternative to platforms such as Docker, Kubernetes, Heroku and Mesosphere, the company says.
  • Stabilizing the world of hot and fast containers
    Containers are moving targets in multiple ways. With multiple tools, frameworks, implementations, and use cases to accomplish any task, it can be a fast-moving chaotic container world, which is a natural consequence of being young and popular. The good news is that all of this creative incubation is hugely productive, and because it's all open source everyone gets to share the benefits of all of this fabulous creativity. The bad news is that it's a giant energized cat herd. How do we know what direction to take? Must we plan for the work we do today to be obsolete in a few months? And, what about portability? I'd like to provide a few insights into the future of containers, and the direction we can expect the state of the art technology to take.
  • How DIGIT Created High Availability on the Public Cloud to Keep Its Games Running
    Emmanuel & Ross: HA is achievable on the public cloud. In our case, we couple redundancy across Availability Zone (AZ) with monitoring and autonomous systems to ensure our games can keep running. Using only one AZ will not ensure HA, as that entire zone could fail for a short time. Each of our applications runs in multiple containers at the same time. They're are all being monitored to handle current load. When one container is down, another takes its place. The same applies for all parts of our infrastructure. All services are autoscaling and behind a service discovery system. On top of this, nodes in our cluster are deployed across multiple AZs, each of which being an isolated network with its own NAT gateway. This way we can survive a whole zone going down.
  • Citrix Gives Away Netscaler Containers for Free
    Netscaler CPX Express, a developer version of the CPX container, is available for free downloading, the company announced yesterday at LinuxCon North America in Toronto. There’s even a catchy URL for it: microloadbalancer.com
  • LinuxCon: How Facebook Monitors Hundreds of Thousands of Servers with Netconsole
    The original kernel documentation for the feature explains that the netconsole module logs kernel printk messages over UDP, allowing debugging of problems where disk logging fails and serial consoles are impractical. Many organizations will choose to use syslog as a way to track potential server errors, but Owens said kernel bugs can crash a machine, so it doesn't help nearly as much as netconsole. He added that Facebook had a system in the past for monitoring that used syslog-ng, but it was less than 60 percent reliable. In contrast, Owens stated netconsole is highly scalable and can handle enormous log volume with greater than 99.99 percent reliability. "Netconsole is fanatically easy to deploy," Owens said. "Configuration is independent of the hardware and by definition you already have a network."

Android 7.0 Nougat

  • Android 7.0 Nougat review—Do more on your gigantic smartphone
    After a lengthy Developer Preview program starting in March, the final version of Android 7.0 (codenamed "Nougat") is finally launching today. The OS update will slowly begin to rollout to devices over the next few weeks. This year, Google is adding even more form factors to the world's most popular operating system. After tackling watches, phones, tablets, TVs, and cars, Nougat brings platform improvements aimed at virtual reality headsets and—with some help from Chrome OS—also targets laptops and desktops.
  • Google Android 7.0 Nougat Review – Surprisingly Uninspiring
    Since the past couple of years, Android updates have hit a concrete wall. Feature additions have gotten pretty mundane while focus on under the hood changes have become key for Google. Obviously, that’s a good thing, for some folks out there, but it’s a approach that doesn’t stand the test of time really very well. Users get frustrated after seeing the same thing over and over again. Same is absolutely true when you compare Android 7.0 Nougat directly with its predecessor, Android 6.0 Marshmallow.
  • Android 7.0 Nougat review: longer battery life and faster operation
    Android 7.0 Nougat is the new version of Google’s mobile operating system, used by billions of devices around the world. It features longer battery life, improved multitasking and smarter notifications in a slimmed down and refined Android experience – following on the work done in last year’s version 6 Marshmallow It is faster, more polished and a subtly-better experience all-round. Apps install more quickly, the OS can be smaller in size and updates to Android can be installed on the fly, without having to wait for 10 minutes while it reboots, if you have a new device. The new Vulcan API graphics system is also baked in for better gaming performance and Nougat will support Google’s Daydream virtual reality system, eventually. Nougat is not, however, a major visual overhaul of Android. Those that have used Marshmallow on any of Google’s Nexus smartphones or devices with little in the way of modification to Android, such as the OnePlus 3, will instantly recognise it.
  • The Best New Features In Android 7 Nougat
    The OS formerly known as Android N is officially out today for a range of Nexus phones. Now dubbed “Android Nougat”, the new mobile operating system ushers in some noteworthy improvements and new productivity tools which we’ve outlined below. But first, here are the Nexus models that are currently supported by the update:
  • Android 7.0 Nougat: a more powerful OS, made for you
  • Android 7.0 Nougat reviews: Should you upgrade your device?

Leftovers: OSS and Sharing

  • Hazelcast Releases Version 3.7
    Hazelcast, a provider of an open source in-memory data grid, has announced the general availability of Hazelcast 3.7. According to the company, the latest release is 30% faster than previous versions and is the first fully modularized version of Hazelcast. Each client/language and plugin is now available as a module – speeding up the development process for open source contributors, with new features and bug fixes released as modules alongside Hazelcast 3.7. Hazelcast continues to expand its footprint beyond its traditional “Java heartland,” the company says. The Hazelcast open source community has created clients for programming environments including Java, Scala, .Net/C#, C++, Python, Node.js, and Clojure. Java and Scala can be used for both clients and embedded members.
  • Hazelcast releases 3.7: cloud-enabled, 30% faster and the first fully modularized in-memory data grid
  • How to measure your community's health
    How do you measure the health of your community, identify problems, and track progress towards your goals? What should you be measuring? Last month we discussed vanity metrics, those metrics that might sound impressive on the surface, but ultimately give you little insight or guidance to improve the health and well-being of your community. This naturally begs the question: What should you be measuring? And as I mentioned last month, the obvious but annoying answer: It depends. The first and foremost dependency relates to the nature of your community and where you and your members want it to go.
  • First ever FSFE Summit celebrates free software successes
    Free software community members and luminaries will meet up at the BCC in Berlin, from September 2-4 2016, at the first ever Free Software Foundation Europe Summit.
  • Walmart, Comcast Hasten Innovation, Improve Agility With OpenStack
    As new technologies like applications and programming languages are introduced, it's important for companies to remain flexible and fast enough to adapt, which is why Walmart and Comcast have embraced OpenStack. By adopting OpenStack solution OneOps, Walmart doesn't have to spend unnecessary time writing code or automating new processes in order to keep up with new technologies, Andrew Mitry, OpenStack Lead at Walmart, explained today at OpenStack East 2016. Walmart already uses more than 3,000 applications and services and has more than 170,000 cores in more than 30 regions, with more than 60 Open Source products that are deployed more than 40,000 times each month. With OneOps, Walmart can automate low-level processes like load balance and firewalls using OneOps, which Mitry said frees up time and resources to manage more intricate processes that require manual oversight.
  • MySQL daddy Widenius: Open-source religion won't feed MariaDB
    MySQL daddy Monty Widenius has dismissed claims the MariaDB fork is veering away from open source. Rather, the chief technology officer of MariaDB corporation called his firm’s embrace of a commercial licence for part of MariaDB "critical" to delivering new revenue and for the continued development of open-source software. Widenius told The Register in an interview that he believes criticism of MariaDB’s commercial licence for its new database proxy sever, MaxScale 2.0, is motivated by a "religious" belief in free and open source software. Not that Widenius is against the belief per se, he told The Register, it’s just: "Religion doesn't put meat on the table."
  • Percona Celebrates 10 Years of Leading the Open Source Database Revolution
  • Nexenta To Showcase Innovative Open Source-Driven Software-Defined Storage (OpenSDS) And All-Flash Solutions At VMworld 2016
  • Nexenta to Showcase Innovative Open Source-Driven Software-Defined Storage (OpenSDS) and All-Flash Solutions at VMworld 2016
  • Nexenta Brings Open Source-Driven Software-Defined Storage Focus to Dell's EMEA Be Future Ready '16 City Tour
  • Be Bold, Be Curious, and Be Open, Advise Outreachy Participants
    In Tuesday afternoon’s “Kernel Internship Report and Outreachy Panel” session at LinuxCon North America, interns and mentors involved with the Outreachy program spoke enthusiastically of their experiences with the program. The panel was moderated by Karen M. Sandler, Executive Director of the Software Freedom Conservancy, and organizer of Outreachy. Sandler provided an overview of the Outreachy program, which offers a paid three-month internship for women and other underrepresented groups to work on a free and open source software project. Helen M Koike Fornazier, a former Outreachy intern and now a Software Engineer at Collabora, described her Linux kernel project involving video4linux, with Laurent Pinchart as her mentor. She wrote a driver, which simulates some media hardware using the Media API.
  • SNI support added to libtls, httpd in -current
    Joel Sing (jsing@) has added server-side Server Name Indication (SNI) support to libtls and, based on that, to httpd.
  • Koko Open Source Readies Their Summer Soap Box Derby Heroes [Ed: only remotely related]
    Koko Open Source, the education branch of Open Source Gallery, has been holding their Soap Box Summer Workshop and Derby since 2008. And although the kids may be neck and neck as they swoop down the street during the race on August 27, the educational experience plays a major role in this race to the finish line.
  • Digital Asset Holdings to open up DAML for developers
    Digital Asset Holdings, the blockchain start-up commanded by Blythe Masters, has announced that it will be open-sourcing its DAML modelling language. DAML, which Digital Asset describes as a “smart-contact-like” system for financial applications and supporting tools, is hailed by the company as a solution to the current market of modelling languages being unsuitable for regulated financial applications. “Many that are exploring the use of smart contracts — legal agreements written as executable code to automate the processing of rights and obligations on a distributed ledger — are discovering the deficiencies with available smart contract languages,” the firm writes in a statement.

FOSS in Government

  • Uganda eager to tap into open source
    Uganda's Ministry of ICT recently developed a FOSS (Free and Open Source Software) policy to regulate the deployment of open source software and use of open standards to accelerate innovation and develop local content. At the 7th African Conference on Free and Open Source Software (FOSS), organised in conjunction with Uganda's National Information Technology Authority (NITA-U) to encourage industry partnerships and uptake of OSS in East Africa, open software was recognised for its contribution to innovation. Frank Tumwebaze, Minister of ICT and National Guidance in Uganda, said, "Free and open software services will help my ministry to innovate better because it forms the platform (for) many of the innovative ideas. Free and open source software in Uganda is certainly something we have been talking about and I am sure we will do so even more in the next few days. Some of the things Uganda has put in place to harness the benefit from free and open source software include a Software Strategy and Policy in accordance with the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development's (UNCTAD) Trade, Services and Development expert meeting's determination that free and open source software is an inseparable component of the global technology ecosystem."
  • Ireland's govt IT: Recession and job cuts forced us to adapt
    Ireland was hit hard by the global financial crunch of 2007 and 2008. It was the first of the EU member states to slip into recession immediately following the bursting of the economic bubble. As the economy contracted, banks faced default and government debt increased, with Ireland eventually taking an €67.5bn loan from the European Commission, European Central Bank (ECB) and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) Falling tax income and the need to bail out banks saw the Irish government spending in other areas of public life. The government had introduced the Public Sector Recruitment Embargo in 2009, which stopped hiring of all civil servants across government and cut pay and pensions – in return for a promise of no compulsory redundancies.
  • Oh! The Horror! Ireland Stays Enslaved To MS
    For 15 years or so, I was in those same financial straits in schools where I taught and GNU/Linux and FLOSS (Free/Libre Open Source Software) was the obvious solution. Obviously, one is better off to have IT for all rather than paying monopolistic prices for IT for a few. In schools, that meant extending the life of IT, elimination of malware and re-re-reboots, freedom from paper, freight for paper, storage for paper, … For governments freedom from lock-in to M$ and “friends” saved huge sums which could have been better spent on hardware or employees. Sigh.