Intense and thoughtful ranting from the OLPC front

Ivan Krstić has made his way into this blog before. As OLPC’s former director of security architecture and one closely involved with their Peru rollout, his posts offered great insights into just how the XO worked (or was supposed to work) on the backend.

Now he, like Walter Bender, has left OLPC and posted one heck of a rant on Tuesday. Note that the language is a bit rough (Krstić pulls no punches and is obviously angry, so this probably isn’t a site to share with your middle school computer classes; for the rest of us, it’s quite a read).

Krstić, despite being able to run circles around most of us in all things computing, including Linux kernel programming, is no open source fundamentalist (as Nicholas Negroponte has called those who object to porting the Sugar user interface to Windows). However, here is his take on recent attention to Negroponte’s moves towards a Windows deployment:

OLPC should be philosophically pure about its own machines. Being a non-profit that leverages goodwill from a tremendous number of community volunteers for its success and whose core mission is one of social betterment, it has a great deal of social responsibility. It should not become a vehicle for creating economic incentives for a particular vendor.

More Here



Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

OLPC will be popular with musical keyboard software ? Aok ?

Learning program is read, write and arithmetic, so the saying goes. When people stressed out, they are no help. Arithmetic teaching does need books(pictures can replace languages).

On the other hand, OLPC already has all the curriculum in arts(picture taking), paint, and games(mind exercise). It just need music(keyboard to simulate musical instruments) and physical exercise programs which needs a stop watch for competition. Or taking movies(EG&G electronic flash) of sports practice for correct physical forms to play perfectly. There may be some need for crafts on XO by instructions or kits supplementing computer delivery.

I see a little more software and the learning program is in fairly good shape for XO users. But also it means the teacher has to have a network color printer(laser) on the mesh for arts and crafts, maybe even hobbies.

Keep it up, Nicholas Negropointe, or is it Negrover here at Tuxmachines.org?