Language Selection

English French German Italian Portuguese Spanish

Windows vs Linux security report card redux

Filed under
Security

Jeff Jones has expanded his project to count security flaws (publicly reported and fixed) in the major workstation operating systems and his latest numbers show Windows Vista has by far the best security profile when compared to the major Linux distributions.

eff Jones, security strategy director in Microsoft’s Trustworthy Computing group, led a TechEd 2007 discussion on the metrics and techniques used to keep track of vulnerabilities and offered a glimpse at his upcoming report card that compares flaws found/fixed during Vista’s first six months on the market against Windows XP, Red Hat Enterprise Linux 4 WS (full), Ubuntu 6.06 LTS (full), Novell SUSE Linux Enteprise Desktop 10 (full) and Mac OS X 10.4 (Tiger).

Full Post.



The Master of All FUDMeisters

This series of 'studies' gets smashed to pieces time after time and time (see comments in the article for example), but it doesn't stop Microsoft from publishing false figures (READ: lies) and sticking them in pamphlets. Some industry supervision ought to step in and handle this case of misleading benchmarks. They got caught before (e.g. cheating in IBM benchmarks in the most ridiculous of ways. They more recently did this to Novell).

Oh look, another "study"...*yawn*

*Switches to salesman voice*

Do you have a problem with a competitor?

Are you having a difficult time keeping up with them?

Well, don't worry! If you can't compete fairly, attack them publically!

With the new FUDMASTER-2000!

Order yours now, and we'll throw in a free DVD tutorial!

In the DVD, get great hints and tips to FUD your competitors! They won't know what hit them!

If you call in the next 10 minutes, we'll throw in a complementary "throwing chair"! Its a great stress reliever when your competitor annoys you! This is the same one used and certified by Microsoft CEO, Steve Ballmer!

Only 12 easy payments of US$29.95!

Act now!

*Switches OFF salesman voice*

Seriously though, we've been here before.

A Microsoft rep or a paid third-party presents a study which favours them.

They're done it with:

(1) "Get the Facts" website. (LOTS there!)

(2) Bill Hilf (Head of MS's Linux Lab) did it in an attempt to show Linux uses just as much as hardware resources as Windows...This failed miserably when you realise the system you need to run Vista (with all the eyecandy) smoothly.

(3) Attack GPL v3!
http://arstechnica.com/news.ars/post/20070522-microsoft-funds-questionable-study-attacking-gpl-3-draft-process.html

(4) And now this!

The fact is, such studies don't work on us. And how we beat them is to question and explain to others why one should be very skeptical. Any opensource geek knows charts and statistics can be manipulated to favour anyone. All one needs to do is select the right influencing factors to affect the result.

To be honest, you should ignore it. (like the other ones that fade into memory).

Come to think of it, we should file every study MS conducts or pays to be conducted in an archive.

Better yet, we should start a website that collects all MS's propaganda and document the tricks they do! It'll help MS's future competitors! (Gives them a clear view of what to expect!)

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

More in Tux Machines

FPGA add-on boards support Raspberry Pi, BeagleBone Black

Newark Element14’s new ValentFX Logi-Pi and Logi-Bone FPGA add-on boards for the Raspberry Pi and BeagleBone Black feature Arduino and PMOD hooks. We first covered the Logi-Pi and Logi-Bone Logi-Boards back in Sept. 2013 when ValentFX showed off prototypes at the New York Maker Faire. The Logi-Boards, which integrate Xilinx SPARTAN-6 XC6SLX9 FPGAs, and plug into the Linux-based Raspberry Pi or BeagleBone Black hacker boards, respectively, have now reached market, thanks to a partnership with Newark Element14. ValentFX and Newark have also launched a $45.48 Logi-Edu educational board add-on that purports to teach everyday hackers the mysteries of FPGA. Read more

AT&T to begin selling LG G Pad F 8.0 Android tablet on May 29

After releasing its own branded 8-inch Android tablet a mere two weeks ago, AT&T is giving itself some fresh competition. The mobile carrier has announced that it's bringing the LG G Pad F 8.0 to its customers starting on May 29. What's Hot on ZDNet The new model should not be confused with the LG G Pad 8.3, which, while being an older tablet, offers a slightly larger, higher-resolution screen and a faster processor. Rather, it's more of a bigger sibling to the LG G Pad 7.0 that was released late last year, coming with the same 1.2GHz quad-core Qualcomm Snapdragon 400 processor (compared to the 1.7GHz Snapdragon 600 inside the G Pad 8.3). Read more

Review: Kubuntu 15.04 "Vivid Vervet"

This month has been quite busy for me with classes. Now that the semester is finally over, I have a little more time, and that means I have enough time to do a review. It has been a few years since I've reviewed Kubuntu, the officially-supported variant of Ubuntu that uses KDE. Moreover, Kubuntu now features KDE 5 (I know the KDE naming and numbering system has become a lot more complicated, so this is, as a physicist might say, an intentional abuse of notation) as stable for the first time, so I figured I should try this version. I tried it as a live USB made with UnetBootin. Follow the jump to see what it's like. (It should become progressively clearer through this review why there are no pictures.) Read more

Open source data integration with Karma

Karma is a free, an open source data integration tool that makes it easy to convert data from a variety of formats into linked data. I recently attended a half-day workshop on Karma with Pedro Szekely, our instructor. He started by warning us that he knows very little about libraries, but a ton about data. The files we needed for the workshop were on GitHub, if you’re interested in checking it out. You can follow the tutorial steps on the Wiki, and, of course, you can find Karma itself on GitHub. Read more